The 10 Worst NFL Draft Picks of All Time: Heroes to Zeroes

Worst NFL Draft Picks

The NFL Draft is a highly anticipated event that captures the excitement of football fans worldwide. It serves as a gateway for teams to acquire talented players who can potentially reshape the future of their franchises. However, not all draft picks pan out as expected. In fact, some turn out to be colossal disappointments, leaving teams and fans lamenting the missed opportunities. In this article, we delve into the annals of NFL history to explore the 10 worst NFL draft picks of all time, showcasing the ill-fated decisions and the consequences that followed.

The 10 Worst NFL Draft Picks of All Time

Ryan Leaf: The Ultimate Bust

Ryan Leaf’s name was synonymous with greatness during his college days. His performances at Washington State University were nothing short of extraordinary, earning him national recognition and lofty expectations as he entered the 1998 NFL Draft.

The build-up to the 1998 NFL Draft was electric, with Ryan Leaf and Peyton Manning emerging as the top quarterback prospects. Leaf’s raw talent and immense potential led to fierce competition for the coveted first-overall pick.

Unfortunately, Leaf’s professional career failed to live up to the hype. Plagued by inconsistency, off-field issues, and clashes with teammates, Leaf quickly unraveled in the NFL. His lack of maturity and inability to adapt to the demands of the game resulted in a swift fall from grace.

JaMarcus Russell: The Definition of a Bust

JaMarcus Russell’s physical gifts and arm strength were the talk of the town leading up to the 2007 NFL Draft. Hailed as a generational talent, Russell seemed destined for greatness, drawing comparisons to some of the game’s greatest quarterbacks.

The Oakland Raiders, in desperate need of a franchise quarterback, placed their faith in Russell by selecting him with the first overall pick. It was a decision that carried enormous weight, with the hopes of an entire organization resting on his shoulders.

Unfortunately, Russell’s dedication to the game did not match his physical gifts. His work ethic came into question, as did his commitment to his craft. Russell’s lackluster performances on the field only reinforced the notion that he was a colossal bust, failing to live up to the immense expectations placed upon him.

Tony Mandarich: The Incredible Disappointment

Tony Mandarich was a force to be reckoned with during his college career at Michigan State University. His exceptional size, strength, and agility made him an imposing figure on the offensive line, leading to comparisons with some of the game’s greatest linemen.

In 1989, the Green Bay Packers made a franchise-altering decision by selecting Mandarich with the second overall pick. The Packers envisioned him as a cornerstone for their offensive line, poised to protect their quarterback and open up running lanes.

READ MORE: Tom Brady Super Bowl record

Regrettably, Mandarich’s professional career fell far short of expectations. He struggled with injuries, subpar performance, and issues related to substance abuse. Mandarich’s story serves as a cautionary tale, reminding us that even the most promising prospects can disappoint when the bright lights of the NFL shine upon them.

Art Schlichter: A Cautionary Tale

Art Schlichter’s college career was not without its fair share of controversy. As the quarterback for the Ohio State Buckeyes, Schlichter displayed remarkable talent on the field, leading his team to notable victories. However, off the field, his behavior raised concerns and hinted at the troubles that would follow.

Despite the red flags surrounding Schlichter’s personal life, the Indianapolis Colts took a gamble by selecting him with the fourth overall pick in the 1982 NFL Draft. The Colts hoped that his on-field skills would outweigh any off-field distractions.

Unfortunately, Schlichter’s struggles off the field overshadowed his potential on it. He became entangled in a web of gambling addiction, which led to severe financial troubles and legal issues. His inability to focus on his football career and make positive choices ultimately derailed any chance he had of success in the NFL.

Charles Rogers: A Wasted Talent

Charles Rogers’ college achievements at Michigan State University were nothing short of exceptional. As a wide receiver, he displayed remarkable speed, agility, and an innate ability to make acrobatic catches. His performances garnered attention from NFL scouts, setting high expectations for his professional career.

With the second overall pick in the 2003 NFL Draft, the Detroit Lions saw Rogers as a game-changing talent who could transform their struggling offense. They believed he had the potential to become a star wide receiver and provide much-needed excitement for the franchise.

However, Rogers’ time in the NFL was plagued by a series of unfortunate events. Injuries hampered his ability to stay on the field, limiting his opportunities to showcase his skills. Moreover, he struggled with personal issues and faced multiple suspensions for violating the league’s substance abuse policy. Rogers’ promising career was tragically cut short, leaving fans and the Lions organization deeply disappointed.

Akili Smith: The Bengals’ Regret

Akili Smith’s collegiate performances at the University of Oregon caught the attention of NFL scouts. He possessed a strong arm, exceptional athleticism, and the potential to become a dynamic dual-threat quarterback.

In the 1999 NFL Draft, the Cincinnati Bengals took a chance on Smith, selecting him with the third overall pick. They envisioned him as the franchise quarterback who would lead the team to success and revitalize their offense.

READ MORE: Josh Jacobs Fantasy

Unfortunately, Smith’s transition to the professional level was far from smooth. He struggled to adapt to the complexities of the NFL game and failed to consistently deliver accurate passes. Smith’s lack of progression and inability to meet the high expectations placed upon him resulted in a disappointing tenure with the Bengals and a short-lived NFL career.

Tim Couch: Failing to Deliver

Tim Couch’s college career at the University of Kentucky was marked by exceptional performances and record-breaking achievements. As a quarterback, he showcased excellent accuracy, poise in the pocket, and leadership skills that elevated his team’s success.

In the 1999 NFL Draft, the newly reinstated Cleveland Browns held the first overall pick and set their sights on Tim Couch. The Browns believed he possessed the talent and potential to be the face of their franchise as they embarked on their return to the NFL.

Despite his college accolades, Couch faced numerous challenges in the NFL. Injuries plagued his career, hindering his ability to stay on the field and develop a rhythm with his teammates. Additionally, he struggled with inconsistency, often displaying flashes of brilliance but failing to deliver consistent performances that matched the high expectations set for him.

Brian Bosworth: A Boastful Bust

Brian Bosworth, known as “The Boz,” captured the attention of football fans with his flamboyant personality and self-promotion. As a linebacker at the University of Oklahoma, he gained notoriety for his brash attitude and exceptional play, becoming one of college football’s most recognizable figures.

The Seattle Seahawks, enticed by Bosworth’s on-field talent and marketability, made the bold choice to draft him in the 1987 NFL Supplemental Draft. They saw an opportunity to inject excitement into their defense and generate buzz around their franchise.

READ MORE: Best NFL Fan Traditions Ranked

Despite the hype and fanfare, Bosworth’s NFL career fell short of expectations. His on-field performance failed to match his bravado, and injuries further hindered his progress. Bosworth’s lack of sustained success highlighted the importance of substance over style in the professional ranks.

Andre Ware: From Heisman to Forgotten

Andre Ware’s remarkable college season at the University of Houston cannot be overlooked. As a quarterback, he put up record-breaking numbers and earned the prestigious Heisman Trophy, solidifying his status as one of the best players in the nation.

The Detroit Lions, hopeful that Ware’s college success would translate to the NFL, selected him with the seventh overall pick in the 1990 NFL Draft. They envisioned him as their franchise quarterback, capable of leading the team to new heights.

Unfortunately, Ware’s skills did not seamlessly transfer to the NFL. He struggled to adapt to the complexities of professional defenses and lacked the supporting cast necessary for success. Ware’s career trajectory serves as a cautionary tale, reminding us that a stellar college career does not guarantee success at the highest level of the game.

Johnny Manziel: The Fall of “Johnny Football”

Johnny Manziel, better known as “Johnny Football,” captivated audiences with his electrifying style of play at Texas A&M University. His ability to improvise, extend plays, and make dazzling throws endeared him to fans across the nation.

Despite concerns about Manziel’s off-field behavior and his unconventional playing style, the Cleveland Browns took a gamble by selecting him in the first round of the 2014 NFL Draft. They hoped he would inject life into their struggling franchise and become the dynamic quarterback they desperately needed.

Unfortunately, Manziel’s off-field troubles overshadowed his on-field potential. His partying lifestyle and lack of dedication to the game became distractions that impacted his performance. Manziel’s inability to adapt to the NFL game and the pressures that came with it led to a swift decline, ultimately derailing his professional career.


the 10 worst NFL draft picks of all time serve as cautionary tales, illustrating the consequences of poor decision-making, high expectations, off-field issues, and the importance of fit and support systems. Teams and future prospects can learn valuable lessons from these experiences to make wiser draft choices and cultivate an environment that fosters the development and success of young players. By studying the past, teams can improve their drafting strategies and maximize the potential of their draft picks, ultimately leading to a more successful and competitive NFL.

READ MORE: Best NFL Linebackers


Q: Who is considered the ultimate NFL draft bust of all time?

A: The ultimate NFL draft bust of all time is Ryan Leaf.

Q: What were the expectations surrounding JaMarcus Russell in the NFL Draft?

A: JaMarcus Russell was expected to be a franchise quarterback and lead his team to success in the NFL.

Q: Which team made a disastrous choice by selecting Tony Mandarich?

A: The Green Bay Packers made a disastrous choice by selecting Tony Mandarich.

Q: What issues plagued Art Schlichter’s NFL career after being drafted?

A: Art Schlichter’s NFL career was plagued by off-field issues, including gambling addiction and legal troubles.

Q: Which highly talented player failed to make an impact after being drafted by the Detroit Lions in 2003?

A: Charles Rogers, a highly talented wide receiver, failed to make an impact after being drafted by the Detroit Lions in 2003.

Thank you for reading.

Leave a Comment