The Top 10 Best NFL Returners of All Time Ranking

Josh Cribbs: The Modern Return Specialist

Josh Cribbs revolutionized the modern era of return specialists with his versatility and exceptional skills. He excelled in both kickoff and punt returns, showcasing his ability to impact the game from various positions on the field. Cribbs’ impact on the return game for the Cleveland Browns was profound and cemented his status as one of the premier return specialists of his time.

What set Josh Cribbs apart from his peers was his ability to excel in different return roles. Whether it was returning kickoffs or punts, Cribbs consistently displayed exceptional vision, speed, and elusiveness. His versatility allowed the Browns to maximize their scoring opportunities and provided a much-needed spark to the team.

Josh Cribbs was a game-changer for the Cleveland Browns. His ability to flip the field and create scoring opportunities gave the team a significant advantage. Cribbs’ returns often shifted the momentum in favor of the Browns, energizing the entire team and inspiring them to perform at their best. His contributions to the team’s success were recognized not only by the fans but also by the league, earning him multiple Pro Bowl selections and establishing him as one of the most exciting players to watch on game day.

Josh Cribbs’ return skills were truly exceptional. His ability to elude tacklers, change direction on a dime, and accelerate past defenders made him a nightmare for opposing teams. Cribbs holds multiple NFL records, including the most career kickoff return touchdowns, further solidifying his place among the elite return specialists in NFL history. His achievements and impact on the game will be remembered for years to come.

Deion Sanders: Prime Time’s Explosiveness

Deion Sanders, often referred to as “Prime Time,” was a multi-dimensional player who left an indelible mark on the game of football. Known for his unmatched speed, quickness, and playmaking ability, Deion Sanders established himself as one of the most explosive players in NFL history. His exceptional athleticism and versatility allowed him to excel not only as a shutdown cornerback but also as a dynamic return specialist. Sanders’ electrifying returns showcased his playmaking ability and cemented his status as one of the all-time greats.

Deion Sanders was renowned for his blistering speed and quickness. His ability to accelerate in the blink of an eye and leave defenders grasping at air was a sight to behold. Sanders possessed a rare combination of agility and straight-line speed that made him nearly impossible to catch once he had the ball in his hands. His speed allowed him to outrun pursuing defenders and turn ordinary returns into game-changing plays.

Throughout his career, Deion Sanders delivered numerous iconic returns that showcased his exceptional playmaking ability. From his electrifying punt return against the Atlanta Falcons, where he darted through a sea of defenders and raced to the end zone, to his breathtaking kickoff return touchdown in Super Bowl XXX, Sanders consistently provided jaw-dropping moments that left fans in awe. His returns were not just about gaining yards but also about creating excitement and momentum for his team.

Deion Sanders’ impact extended beyond his individual achievements. Throughout his career, he played for multiple teams, including the Atlanta Falcons, San Francisco 49ers, Dallas Cowboys, and Washington Redskins. Sanders brought his dynamic playmaking ability to each team, leaving an indelible mark wherever he went. His contributions on special teams, in addition to his excellence as a cornerback, provided an extra dimension to his teams and made them even more formidable.

Desmond Howard: Super Bowl MVP

Desmond Howard’s performance in Super Bowl XXXI solidified his place among the greatest returners in NFL history. His exceptional returns and versatility played a significant role in the Green Bay Packers championship run, earning him the Super Bowl MVP honors.

Desmond Howard’s performance in Super Bowl XXXI was nothing short of remarkable. He returned a kickoff 99 yards for a touchdown, showcasing his speed and elusiveness on the grandest stage of them all. Howard’s return not only swung the momentum in favor of the Packers but also set the tone for their dominant victory. His ability to rise to the occasion and deliver a game-changing play on such a prominent platform solidified his place in Super Bowl history.

Desmond Howard’s contributions to the Green Bay Packers’ championship run cannot be overstated. His exceptional returns provided the Packers with a significant advantage in field position and energized the team and its fans. Howard’s ability to create scoring opportunities and swing momentum in favor of the Packers played a pivotal role in their successful campaign. His impact on special teams, coupled with his versatility as a receiver, made him an invaluable asset to the team.

Desmond Howard’s versatility as a returner set him apart from his peers. He possessed the speed and elusiveness to excel in both punt returns and kickoff returns. Howard’s ability to contribute in multiple facets of the return game made him a constant threat and forced opposing teams to game plan specifically to contain him. His versatility added another dimension to the Packers’ special teams unit and contributed to their overall success.

Devin Hester vs. Deion Sanders: Who’s the Greatest?

The debate over the greatest returner of all time often comes down to Devin Hester and Deion Sanders. Both players revolutionized the return position and left an indelible mark on the game. Comparing their statistics, impact, and style of play is an engaging topic that ignites passionate discussions among NFL fans and experts.

Devin Hester and Deion Sanders had contrasting styles and roles as return specialists. Hester was primarily known for his prowess as a punt and kickoff returner, while Sanders, in addition to his return skills, was an exceptional cornerback. Analyzing their careers side by side allows us to gain a deeper appreciation for their respective contributions to the game.

In terms of statistics, both Hester and Sanders had impressive numbers. Hester holds the NFL record for the most career return touchdowns, showcasing his ability to find the end zone and change the game’s outcome. Sanders, on the other hand, had a remarkable knack for timely returns and game-altering plays, with numerous memorable moments etched in NFL history.

When assessing their impact, Hester’s electrifying returns provided a significant boost to the Chicago Bears and elevated their special teams unit to new heights. His contributions often swung the momentum in favor of his team and instilled fear in opponents. Sanders, with his dual role as a cornerback and returner, influenced multiple teams throughout his career. His game-changing returns and shutdown coverage made him a complete package and a game-wrecker for opposing offenses.

Engaging in the debate over the greatest returner of all time ultimately comes down to personal preference and the criteria used to evaluate greatness. Some may argue that Hester’s record-breaking career and unmatched ability to score touchdowns on returns make him the clear choice. Others may lean towards Sanders, considering his versatility as a cornerback and return specialist, which made him a game-changer on both sides of the ball.

Ultimately, the debate over the greatest returner of all time is subjective, as both Hester and Sanders have left an enduring legacy in the NFL. Their unique skills, impact on the game, and ability to create unforgettable moments have forever solidified their places among the all-time greats.

Rick Upchurch: The Forgotten Star

While Rick Upchurch may not be as widely recognized as some of the other return specialists on this list, his contributions to the return game should not be overlooked. Upchurch played a pivotal role in the success of the Denver Broncos during the 1970s and early 1980s, pioneering techniques and strategies that influenced future generations of returners.

Rick Upchurch’s impact on the return game can be described as pioneering. He brought a level of creativity and innovation to the field, revolutionizing the way returns were executed. Upchurch introduced new techniques, such as using the sidelines as an additional blocker or setting up his returns with deceptive moves, that confounded defenders and maximized his yardage gains. His contributions laid the groundwork for future return specialists to study and emulate.

Rick Upchurch’s impact on the Denver Broncos cannot be overstated. His exceptional returns provided the team with a significant advantage in field position and often set the tone for their offensive drives. Upchurch’s ability to create scoring opportunities and swing momentum in favor of the Broncos played a pivotal role in their success during that era. His contributions were recognized by his teammates, coaches, and fans, establishing him as one of the key figures in Bronco’s history.

Rick Upchurch’s innovative approach to the return game influenced future generations of returners. His techniques and strategies became part of the playbook for aspiring return specialists. Upchurch’s impact extended beyond his own career, as his contributions shaped the way the position is approached and taught to this day. His influence can be seen in the style and techniques employed by modern return specialists, highlighting his lasting impact on the game.

Mel Gray: The Speed Demon

Mel Gray, often referred to as the “Speed Demon,” was a force to be reckoned with on the football field. His blazing speed and game-breaking returns made him one of the most exciting returners in NFL history. Gray’s accomplishments with the St. Louis Cardinals solidified his place among the elite return specialists of his era.

Mel Gray’s blazing speed was his trademark. He possessed the rare combination of agility and acceleration that allowed him to leave defenders in the dust. Gray’s explosive returns were characterized by long touchdown runs and impressive yardage gains. His ability to break tackles and weave through the coverage unit made him a constant threat to score whenever he touched the ball.

During his tenure with the St. Louis Cardinals, Mel Gray showcased his exceptional return skills and left an indelible mark on the franchise’s history. Gray consistently provided a spark for the Cardinals, flipping the field and creating scoring opportunities. His contributions were instrumental in the team’s success, and he became a fan favorite in St. Louis.

Mel Gray’s impact on the return game extended beyond his individual achievements. His blazing speed and game-breaking returns influenced how opponents approached kickoff and punt coverage. Opposing teams had to alter their strategies and dedicate extra attention to containing Gray, which often resulted in improved field position for the Cardinals’ offense. Gray’s influence on the return game cannot be understated, as he set a standard of excellence for future generations of return specialists.

Billy “White Shoes” Johnson: The Dance Master

Billy “White Shoes” Johnson brought an entertaining flair to the return game with his charismatic style and signature touchdown celebrations. His contributions to the success of the Houston Oilers, both as a returner and a receiver, cemented his unique place in returner history.

Billy “White Shoes” Johnson was known not only for his exceptional return skills but also for his charismatic style and entertaining celebrations. After scoring a touchdown, Johnson would break into a dance routine that quickly became his trademark. His celebrations added an element of joy and showmanship to the game, endearing him to fans and making him a memorable figure in NFL history.

Billy Johnson’s contributions to the Houston Oilers were significant. His explosive returns and dynamic playmaking ability provided a valuable weapon for the team. Johnson’s ability to flip the field and generate excitement energized the entire Oilers squad and their fanbase. His impact extended beyond special teams, as he also contributed as a wide receiver, further solidifying his importance to the team’s success.

Billy “White Shoes” Johnson’s unique combination of exceptional return skills and entertaining celebrations set him apart from other return specialists. His charismatic personality and style of play made him a fan favorite and left a lasting impression on the game. Johnson’s influence on the return position can still be felt today, as his captivating celebrations and charismatic approach have inspired subsequent generations of players to bring their own flair and personality to the field.

Conclusion

Reflecting on the top 10 best NFL returners of all time, it is evident that the position of a return specialist is filled with exceptional talent and game-changing abilities. From Devin Hester’s record-breaking career to Deion Sanders’ unmatched explosiveness, these players have left an indelible mark on the game. Their exceptional skills, impact on their respective teams, and lasting legacies have solidified their places among the all-time greats in the history of the NFL.

FAQ

What criteria were considered in determining the top returners? 

Thank you for reading.
https://www.thegridironsport.com/